Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine Book Club Discussion Questions

Discussion Questions:

1.The book starts off with descriptions of Eleanor’s job. Eleanor had been working at her job since she was 21. She said that the owner felt sorry for her and gave her the job because she had a black eye and a broken arm in a sling. What impressions did you have of Eleanor? What did you think this book was going to be about? Why do you think the author included this at the beginning?

2. Eleanor is academically smart having a degree in Classics but her colleagues refer to her such as “wacko jacko” or “harry potter”. Does the way Eleanor look and how she behaves socially call for such name calling? Do you have ‘nick names’ for your colleagues?

3. As we get into the book we discover that Eleanor has been in foster care and children’s homes as a child. Do you think that her social awkwardness and solitary lifestyle is a result of this type of upbringing? Or do you think that it’s her Mummy that has made her like that?

4. Why does Eleanor lead a regimented and lonely life?

5. Which character did you like the most? Why?

6. Eleanor and Raymond’s friendship grow as a result of them helping Sammy Thom when he fell and banged his head. Why was Eleanor reluctant to help Sammy right away?

7. Eleanor talks with Mummy every Wednesday. What is her relationship with her Mummy like? Why does Eleanor want to talk to her?

8. Eleanor and Raymond’s act of kindness in helping Sammy changed all three of their lives. Do you think their lives changed for the better? Do you believe in karma?

9. What your impression of Raymond? Did you like him? Why?

10. Eleanor develops a crush on Johnnie Lomond a singer she sees performing. She starts on a path to transform her the way she looks. She was fine with the way she looked before but rationally argued that if she was to be a singer’s girlfriend she would have to look socially acceptable. Why does she think he’s ‘husband material’? What qualities in a man is she looking for? Have you done something like that when you had a crush?

11. The book covers many themes, friendship, kindness, isolation, loneliness, grief, mental health, depression to name a few. Which theme/s spoke to you? Which theme made an impact the most?

12. “When the silence and the aloneness press down and around me, crushing me, carving through me like ice, I need to speak aloud sometimes, if only for proof of life.”

Eleanor talks to her plant Polly, what does this say about her and her state of mind? How does she change towards the end?

13. Eleanor often mentions others lack of social skills or communications skills. Do you think that Eleanor blames others for their faults as a defense mechanism? What is the rationing behind her thoughts? Do you think she acts in a logical manner?

14. When does Eleanor change and become hopeful? What signs do you see that show her new outlook?

15. Did you find the book funny? Which part made you laugh?

16. What did you think of the ending? Did you enjoy it? Which part did you like?

17. After reading Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine, who would you recommend it to?

Enhance your book club:

Check out Summary of Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely by Gail Honeyman for conversation starters, and a deeper understanding of the book.

Check out our review of Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine!

2 thoughts on “Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine Book Club Discussion Questions

  1. I haven’t finished this book yet, because it bores me. Yes it’s cute and funny at times, but I just got so bored with it. Does it have redemption in the end? I’ll finish it, but it’s not a top priority with many other books to read. Not sure how it got 4-5 stars from most readers.

    1. Hi Kristine!
      I am surprised that you’re finding it boring. I thought it was charming and loved the protagonist.
      We all have different tastes. Do let me know what you think of it after you finish. I’d be interested to see if you change your mind. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.